Ask a Bible question
Explore a topic, clarify a difficult idea, or connect passages across Scripture.
From a question to the Word
Read the opening below, then expand the complete saved response, including its study steps, related teachings, and follow-up questions. Open the Scripture references here and test the reasoning.
Reading this example uses no credits. Standard replies use 1 credit.
The Assistant can make mistakes. Scripture remains the standard.
Browse free teachingsThe Assistant draws on Scripture and our published understanding, shaped by more than 15 years of ministry and 700+ teachings. It can make mistakes. It supports your study and does not replace prayer, discernment, or fellowship with others.
Did Jesus abolish the law? How should we understand Matthew 5:17–19 alongside Paul’s teaching that we are not under the law?
No—119 Ministries teaches that YHWH’s law, the Torah, has not been abolished. Yeshua (Jesus) affirms its continuing authority in Matthew 5:17–19, while Paul’s statement that believers are “not under law but under grace” describes freedom from sin’s dominion and the law’s condemnation—not freedom to reject YHWH’s instruction. Obedience does not earn salvation; it is the grateful, Spirit-enabled response to salvation through Messiah.
The key is to distinguish the law as instruction, the law’s judgment against sin, and attempts to obtain justification through law-keeping. Those are related questions, but they are not interchangeable.
Yeshua begins by explicitly rejecting the idea that His mission abolishes the Law or the Prophets:
“Don’t think that I came to destroy the law or the prophets. I didn’t come to destroy, but to fulfill.” — WEB
“Fulfill” must be understood in a way that respects the contrast Yeshua makes. He does not say, “We thought the law would continue, but now it will be abolished through fulfillment.” He says His purpose is not to destroy it.
We understand His fulfillment to include bringing the Law and the Prophets to their intended expression through His teaching, obedience, and messianic work. But we should not settle the question through the word “fulfill” alone. The following verses explain what His statement means for His disciples.
“For most certainly, I tell you, until heaven and earth pass away, not even one smallest letter or one tiny pen stroke shall in any way pass away from the law, until all things are accomplished.” — WEB
Yeshua emphasizes the law’s enduring authority down to its smallest details. Then He draws a practical conclusion:
“Therefore, whoever shall break one of these least commandments and teach others to do so, shall be called least in the Kingdom of Heaven; but whoever shall do and teach them shall be called great in the Kingdom of Heaven.” — WEB
Notice the word “therefore.” His instruction to do and teach the commandments follows directly from His statement that He has not come to abolish them.
The passage’s movement is straightforward:
This is why we do not interpret “fulfill” as “make obedience unnecessary.” That would reverse the practical conclusion Yeshua Himself gives.
The surrounding sermon also concerns genuine obedience—not merely external appearances. Yeshua addresses anger, coveting, faithfulness, truthfulness, and love. He brings the heart into submission to YHWH rather than treating outward compliance as sufficient.
Before interpreting “not under law,” we should hear Paul’s direct answer to whether faith nullifies the law:
“Do we then nullify the law through faith? May it never be! No, we establish the law.” — WEB
Whatever Paul means elsewhere, he does not intend faith to make YHWH’s law void.
Later, Paul asks whether the law itself is sin. His answer is again emphatic: absolutely not. Instead, the law identifies sin; he illustrates this with the command against coveting (Romans 7:7).
He then concludes:
“Therefore the law indeed is holy, and the commandment holy, and righteous, and good.” — WEB
Paul also describes the law as spiritual and speaks of delighting in YHWH’s law (Romans 7:14; Romans 7:22).
These statements do not, by themselves, explain every difficult passage. They do establish essential boundaries: Paul does not regard Torah as an evil system from which righteousness requires escape. His concern is with sin, condemnation, human weakness, and the misuse of law as a means of justification.
We should therefore read Paul’s challenging statements alongside both his positive statements and Yeshua’s teaching—not set one group of passages against the other.
Here is the statement at the center of the question:
“For sin will not have dominion over you, for you are not under law, but under grace.” — WEB
The opening clause matters: “Sin will not have dominion over you.”
Paul’s subject throughout Romans 6 is liberation from slavery to sin:
Within that argument, being “under grace” cannot mean that conduct no longer matters. Grace changes whom we serve.
Paul immediately prevents that misunderstanding:
“What then? Shall we sin, because we are not under law, but under grace? May it never be!” — WEB
That verse is especially important because Paul repeats the exact contrast—law and grace—and rejects using it as a reason to sin.
Scripture identifies sin as lawlessness: Torah-lessness, or rejection of YHWH’s instruction (1 John 3:4). Paul likewise uses Torah to identify sin in Romans 7:7. Therefore, release from sin’s dominion cannot reasonably mean release into rejecting the instruction that identifies sin.
Our understanding: In Romans 6:14, believers are no longer under the law’s condemning judgment as people enslaved to sin. Through Messiah, they stand under YHWH’s undeserved favor and are freed to serve Him.
An important qualification: Romans 6:14 does not literally contain the words “condemnation” or “law of sin and death.” Those words explain our contextual interpretation; they are not additions to Paul’s sentence. The basis for that interpretation becomes clearer in Romans 8.
Some Christians instead understand “not under law” as release from the Mosaic covenant’s governing authority, while still affirming that believers must obey Messiah. We recognize that this is not necessarily an argument for unrestricted sin. Our disagreement concerns whether Paul removes Torah’s authority as instruction. We believe Romans 3:31, Romans 7:12, and Romans 8:4 favor continuity rather than abolition.
Paul uses several expressions involving “law,” so we should not assume every occurrence has the same referent or function.
For example:
These are not interchangeable names for Torah.
Paul states:
“There is therefore now no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus … For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus made me free from the law of sin and of death.” — WEB
Here Paul explicitly names both condemnation and the law of sin and death. That is why we understand these concepts as illuminating his earlier contrast between being under law and under grace.
But what does this freedom produce?
Romans 8:3–4 explains that YHWH accomplished through His Son what the law, weakened by human flesh, could not accomplish, so that the law’s righteous requirement would be fulfilled in those who walk according to the Spirit.
The problem was not that YHWH gave bad instruction. The problem was that sinful humanity needed forgiveness and transformation—not merely a written command.
Paul then contrasts the Spirit-led life with the fleshly mindset:
“Because the mind of the flesh is hostile toward God; for it is not subject to God’s law, neither indeed can it be.” — WEB
In Paul’s argument, refusing submission to YHWH’s law characterizes the flesh—not spiritual maturity.
This also helps explain being “dead to the law” and “released from the law” in Romans 7:4–6. We understand those statements as release from the law’s condemning claim through participation in Messiah’s death, enabling believers to bear fruit for YHWH and serve in the newness of the Spirit. They do not mean that the Spirit now teaches rejection of the very instruction Paul calls holy and good.
Galatians strongly rejects obtaining justification through works of law:
Galatians 2:16 teaches that a person is not justified by works of law but through faith in Messiah.
We affirm that without qualification: Torah-obedience cannot purchase forgiveness, erase past guilt, or replace trust in Messiah.
Paul’s warning in Galatians 5:4 makes the issue explicit: he addresses those seeking to be “justified by the law.” The problem is not a believer gratefully obeying YHWH. It is reliance on law-keeping or circumcision as the basis of acceptance before Him.
Several distinctions help:
Redeemed from the curse does not mean redeemed from obedience.
Galatians 3:13 says Messiah redeemed us from the curse of the law. The curse is the judgment pronounced against disobedience; it is not a declaration that YHWH’s instruction is itself a curse.
The law cannot impart the life we need.
Galatians 3:21 explicitly asks whether the law opposes YHWH’s promises and answers no. Yet the law cannot give life. Recognizing that limitation does not make it false or useless as instruction.
The Spirit and Torah are not opponents.
Galatians 5:18 says those led by the Spirit are “not under the law.” Paul then contrasts the works of the flesh with the Spirit’s fruit and observes that there is no law against such fruit (Galatians 5:19–23).
We understand this consistently with Romans: the Spirit frees believers from condemnation and produces conduct in harmony with YHWH’s instruction. The Spirit does not lead people into the very transgressions the law condemns.
Nor does “the law of Christ” introduce a rival standard. We understand it as Torah interpreted and embodied by Messiah, with love for YHWH and neighbor at its center. Bearing one another’s burdens fulfills that instruction in practice (Galatians 6:2).
The New Covenant promise provides the larger framework.
In Jeremiah 31:31–33, YHWH promises a New Covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah. A central feature is that He will put His Torah within His people and write it on their hearts.
Ezekiel describes the accompanying transformation:
“I will put my Spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes. You will keep my ordinances and do them.” — WEB
The promised direction is unmistakable:
We therefore understand the New Covenant not as permission to disregard Torah, but as YHWH’s provision for forgiveness and heart-level covenant faithfulness. This is the framework through which we read Paul’s contrast between the letter and the Spirit.
This does not mean every command is performed identically by every person. Commands must be understood according to their stated audience, role, and circumstances. But contextual application is different from declaring parts of YHWH’s instruction abolished.
Two opposite errors should be avoided:
Trying to earn salvation through obedience.
We depend on YHWH’s grace through faith in Messiah, not an obedience record that makes us deserving. Ephesians 2:8–9 excludes boasting in works.
Treating grace as freedom from obedience.
Ephesians 2:10 immediately says believers are created in Messiah for good works. Grace does not merely forgive a life of sin; it teaches us to turn from it.
A sound approach is to:
Obedience is the fruit of living faith—not a substitute for it.
Matthew 5:17–19 and Paul’s teaching belong together. Yeshua upholds Torah; Paul rejects its misuse as a means of justification and announces freedom from the condemnation and bondage brought by sin. The Spirit then enables the obedience that the New Covenant promises.
We are not saved by keeping the law, but salvation does not make YHWH’s instruction irrelevant. We encourage testing this understanding by reading Matthew 5:17–20 and Romans 6–8 as complete arguments, alongside Jeremiah 31:31–33 and Ezekiel 36:26–27.
Reply with “1”, “2”, or “3”, type your own prompt, or click "New Chat" for a new topic or context.
This saved example includes the complete study response, related teachings, and suggested prompts. The question above is a suggested starting point; the export did not include the original prompt, response power or credit cost. Response length and detail vary. Reading this example uses no credits.
Select a Scripture reference to read the passage here in the World English Bible (WEB). Test every response against Scripture.
Explore this questionA place to begin
Create an account or sign in, then review your question in Chat before sending.
Explore a topic, clarify a difficult idea, or connect passages across Scripture.
Look at its context, follow related passages, and consider what it means.
Discover studies from 119 Ministries that help you take the next step.
Browse the teaching libraryBring a transcript, article, or document and examine its reasoning alongside Scripture.
Explore Review ContentAsk out loud, explore follow-up questions, and return to saved study notes. Choose a voice and set your session limit before you begin. Talk uses 3 credits per connected minute and needs a reliable internet connection.
Try a voice conversationHow it works
Tell the Assistant what you want to understand. No special wording is needed.
Read the explanation, ask for clarity, and explore the Scripture and teachings cited.
Read the passages in context and test the reasoning before applying or sharing it.
See the study tools and learn how to begin your first conversation.
A static preview of the Chat layout, with demonstration history and an actual response excerpt.
Keep studying at your pace
Begin with 25 welcome credits when you create a free account. Choose a plan when you are ready.
Voice conversations use 3 credits per connected minute, including research. Set a session limit before connecting; unused reserved credits return when you pause.
Monthly subscription
$4.99/ month
125 credits each month
Monthly subscription
$9.99/ month
250 credits each month
Monthly subscription
$19.99/ month
500 credits each month
Unused monthly credits do not roll over. Welcome and add-on credits do not expire.
One-time purchase
Need a little more? Add credits without a monthly subscription.
Our published Bible teachings remain freely available. Each personalized Assistant response requires paid computing resources to find relevant material and generate an answer. Assistant plans and credits help cover those ongoing technology costs and keep this study tool available.
You can continue exploring our free teaching library anytime.
Paid plans help cover the cost of replies and support 119 Ministries’ teaching work.